Sean Dyche has sparked controversy by comparing Liverpool’s historic Premier League triumph under Jurgen Klopp with the ongoing debate surrounding Manchester City’s financial charges.
The former Everton manager believes City should have their trophies voided if appropriate sanctions are imposed, but his reasoning included a questionable reference to Liverpool’s 2019/20 title.
For Liverpool supporters, the comparison will understandably raise eyebrows.
Klopp’s side dominated that campaign, ending the club’s 30-year wait for a league championship in extraordinary fashion.
Yet Dyche suggested the coronavirus pandemic had left a small question mark over their achievement.
Dyche questions Liverpool’s historic triumph
Speaking on Keys and Gray’s YouTube channel, Dyche discussed how Manchester City’s previous successes should be treated.
“I would void the things they have won,” he explained.
However, the former Burnley manager then introduced Liverpool’s title-winning campaign into the conversation.
“You know when Liverpool won the league, and it was in the pandemic. You know they were brilliant that season.”
Dyche suggested the unusual circumstances surrounding football’s suspension had affected perceptions of Liverpool’s achievement.
“So, it sort of still adds a bit of a question mark. A tiny little one.”
Liverpool’s title deserves greater respect
There is one glaring problem with Dyche’s comparison.
Liverpool were already 25 points clear when Premier League football was suspended in March 2020.
With just nine matches remaining, Klopp’s side had effectively established an unassailable advantage before games resumed behind closed doors.
The pandemic did not create Liverpool’s dominance.
That advantage was built through months of exceptional performances against the strongest competition English football could offer.
Meanwhile, Manchester City’s financial charges concern alleged breaches of Premier League regulations, which the club has denied.
Those allegations are entirely separate from the circumstances surrounding Liverpool’s championship.
Whether City should face retrospective sporting sanctions remains a matter for the relevant authorities.
However, suggesting Liverpool’s title carries a comparable question mark feels particularly unfair.
Klopp’s team earned their championship through performances on the pitch, long before the pandemic interrupted proceedings.
Liverpool supporters have every reason to reject any suggestion that their achievement deserves an asterisk.