If he does return, he maybe sold on to another club anyway, or Kenny Dalglish may opt to keep him. Some Reds fans would be delighted at him staying, although I am slightly more sceptical about the chance of him succeeding if he returns. Although he showed a very good passing range and skill on the ball when he was with us in his first season, I am not convinced he really has the right attributes to make it playing in central midfield.
For Juventus, he has played generally in a deeper lying midfield position than he did at Liverpool, and I don’t see him being as effective in the role in the Premier League. Although he has played well in Italy, he has gone off the boil, like his team, over the past few months, contributing to the lack of will on Juve’s part to offer the agreed £13.5m amount. If he does return to play in central midfield here, he would need to be combative in central areas and that is not in Aquilani’s game. Many Reds fans have complained about the lack of good tackling from Raul Meireles in the same areas and I feel Aquilani would even be less effective than the Portuguese man.
The Italian would certainly add some good squad depth to the squad, and be a good alternative to either Gerrard or Meireles in an advanced midfield role, but for me, the money we could get from his sale, could be used to either bolster our holding midfield or wing options, which would greatly improve the depth and variety in our squad. Aquilani has undoubted natural talent, but for me, he is not the style of player we are looking for at the moment. What do you think of Aquilani’s potential return?
Follow us on twitter @live4Liverpool or like us on Facebook
Live4Liverpool is recruiting columnists. For further info contact the site editor at live4liverpool@snack-media.com
INTRODUCING CRYSIS 2!
This week it is former LFC WAG Edita Hortova!
————–
CLICK ON THE IMAGE OR HERE TO GET TO THE GALLERY
–
I would love to see him back. He began to perform towards the close of the season, and I was shocked when he was loaned out. Even as a squad player he adds a lot of depth, and that is something we need to address. Surely the Liverpool squad is in a healthier shape with Alberto rather than without Alberto?
Well said Rav
I would love Aquaman back at Liverpool. How many times have we lacked creativity when Stevie G is out? The Italian was starting to show us all why Rafa had faith in him. And lets remember the guy has been injury free all season – not bad for an injury prone player!
The football is not in question, we just do not want someone sulking (Torres) because he does not want to be here 100%.
He would also need to make a big effort to learn English, which I think you will find he did not do when here before. If he doesn’t he will feel isolated and unhappy!!!
This is a point well made. It was well documented that he was not even attending his English lessons.
Deffinetly have him back,, he has payed well for Juve all season !! We are likely to be in many competitions next year and we will need strength and Depth ( Lucas, Gerrard, Meireles, Aqua )
Sell cole,poulsen,jovanovic,ngog,degen,el-zhar,aurelio,insua,maxi anymore?? :-p
I hope we get aquilani back, he is a very good passer and playmaker, no need to spend riddiculously on Adam !!
We need Young, Contreao, Cahill or even bring Ayala back, he is good …
He wouldn’t have gone in the first place if it hadn’t been for that brain dead excuse for a manager Hodgson. His idea of a good player was Poulson and Koncheski, see how that worked out.
Totally have him back, he was not given enough time to settle and like another said, idiot Hodgson doesn’t know a quality footballer when he see’s one.
Liverpool are sorely lacking a creative midfielder, Cole isn’t going to come any time soon, the creative spark is not so prevalent with Stevie G, we need another Alonso and Aquaman is it.
He will give Carroll and Suarez a lot more options and I think he and Suarez in particular would be an awesome duo.
Please, please Kenny, bring back Aquaman, there are not many top flight creative players left out there, so we do need to hold onto this one.
Sorry David, you are so wrong on this, Lucas was just the same when he started at LFC, of course Aquaman needs to adjust, but he should not be doing the muscle work, look at Nasri, look at Anelka, look at Yossi, or our Joe Cole, they are not heavyweight midfielders, but then they don’t need to be, they are the one’s that will ghost in or make that defence splitting pass, if you knock them down because of their skill on the ball, you concede a free kick in a dangerous area.
This is the role of the Aquaman, let the others deal with tough tacklers, Aqua brings the finesse needed, Liverpool don’t need lots of players barging opponents off the ball, they need someone who can pass and has vision…who can spray the ball with pinpoint accuracy, whose nimbleness allows him the balance to dance past defenders, whose vision can spot the movement of the striker before the defender is aware.
Every team needs one (see Messi or Ronaldo) to make that final jump to being the best, see Dennis Bergkamp, see Eric Cantona, see Zola, see the point I am making?
I have watched aqua this year many of times his form for juventus is good saying his form has dipped is wrong juve struggle to score goals and only really have 3 really creative players 1 being aqua. Juve are struggling with the loss of quagliarella. Aqua has been 1 of there best players easy. I also watched Italy play Slovenia Friday night aquilani started and was brilliant again yeh he lacks a bit of bite but his creativity would be a welcomed edition. He needed game time now he has got it he had even broke into the national team. Bring him back can’t believe we let him go in the 1st place
When he first came to Liverpool, he was injured and was out for quite a while. After he recovered, he was expected to slot in and replace Alonso from the off. That was unrealistic of Rafa, and consequently he never really found his feet.
Now he’s had a season playing and is back to full fitness, I think he’s do much better this time around. I’d love to see him come back and get a few games. Of course, he won’t be playing week in, week out, but he’ll add something extra to our squad.
If he does come back and make a serious go of it, I’d take advantage of this and rather than bringing in another midfield player in the summer, focus on the wings and full back areas.
With Stevie getting older and injuries cropping up more often amongst our squad, I think another solid midfield player in the squad is much prefered over bringing in someone like Charlie Adam, who, while a great player, has had only one season at the top level.
Either way i’d be happy with the outcome.either Juventus pay us 14million and take him which money could be spent on a winger,like AShley Young or Arda Turan for example,or he comes back and we have a better squad depth in midfield with the likes of Lucas Leiva,Steven Gerrard,Raul Meireles,Alberto Aquilani and Charlie Adam(i think we’ll get him).i mean that in both cases i’d be happy with the outcome.in the case i’d get angry is if we lowered our price like 8million for example where 8million are too little for Alberto.Damien Comolli and King Kenny(if he stays) will have to find a way in this one and i hope they find the correct one.YNWA
if he come back… he must fight place with meireles… no automatic add..
Get him back. he is young and talented.he has more years to go.kenny know how to play him.hodgson does not.enough with hodgson.lets move forward.
didn’t he get the most assists in the league in the second hal of his irst season? bring him back either way – we want class, he is class
If he’s willing to give it a 100% and not sulk like you now who, why not? He actually was our best player towards the end of last season when he had a run of games (6 assists and 2 goals…better stats than that waste of space Anderson over his entire Utd. career.)Lucas can protect the defence, Aqua can spray passes forward and wide and Meireles can make those forward runs that he loves to make. Centre midfield sorted out pretty much.
I would prefer to sell it is a good player but not the kind of player
we wanted to replace Xabi Alonso, with money from the sale
could sign a Boudebouz that is younger, with a bright future and
already said he wants to play in Liverpool.