David Moyes was spot on in his assessment that Martin Atkinson had spoiled what was building up to be a scintillating Merseyside derby. No one is suggesting he did this deliberately. Whilst his decision to send of Jack Rodwell, for a supposedly reckless tackle favoured Liverpool, Atkinson’s last red card in this fixture (the dismissal of Sotirios Kyrgiakos) favoured Everton.
People will no doubt point to the fact that the Greek defender’s dismissal was justified, which it certainly was. However, Atkinson neglected to send off Fellani for his two-footed lunge in the same tackle.
The main issue is that Martin Atkinson made a mistake. What has been debated since last Saturday is should he have been made to come out and explain his decision to red card Rodwell; to explain what it was he saw at Goodison Park that no one else in the stadium or at home could see. After all, numerous replays proved that Atkinson had a completely unobstructed view of the incident. Admittedly, the theatrics of Suarez didn’t help the situation, but the referee is expected to judge the challenge in itself.
Moyes’ criticism, whilst fully justified here will have come as no surprise. In general, managers, it must be said are quick to scape-goat refs. If their star striker misses a hatful of chances, but the ref fails to give a throw-in on the halfway line they’ll always blame the ref.
If Arsene Wenger was a sitcom character his catchphrase would be ‘I didn’t see it’. But this only applies to misdemeanours committed by his own side. I recall a game a few years ago at Anfield where he claimed Liverpool’s equaliser came from a corner that shouldn’t have been given (despite repeated replays proving inconclusive).
Referees exist in a one-shot world. They have seconds to make a decision and they must always make it correctly. When they don’t, the fans and the media converge on them. We’re all armchair pundits who have screamed for a penalty, then accused the referee of bias against ‘us’ only for a replay to prove there was no offence. Referees don’t have that luxury.
Just why anyone would want to be a referee anyway is beyond me. Every week there are tales of abuse and, particularly in the amateur leagues of violence against the match officials. Even at children’s levels the abuse from parents borders on criminal.
The men, women and occasionally teenagers who referee these matches get paid around £50 a match. Hardly worth it for what they put up with. In 2009 assaults on referees occurred over 300 times.
Football at the elite level is now a billion pound industry where errors cost points and relegation costs tens of millions. The sport is also far quicker than it was, requiring referees to be capable of certain levels of fitness. One recalls Sir Alex Ferguson questioning the fitness of Alan Wiley after a game with Sunderland. Ferguson scoffed: ‘He was not fit enough for a game of that standard…it is an indictment of our game.’ Prozone stats showed that Wiley had run nearly 12km during the game, more than all bar seven of the players on the pitch.
The pace of the game is important when considering the decisions referees have to make. Thanks to Sky the armchair fan is used to seeing the same incident in super slow motion from five or six different angles. After all this analysis they will then make their assessment on whether the decision was correct.
The referees have none of that. They make their decision based on one viewing at normal time and have to make it in a matter of seconds. It is inevitable that they will make mistakes.
Managerial pressure is another aspect of the game that referees have to deal with. Alex Ferguson has made a career out of questioning the official’s decisions but, in the case of Martin Atkinson (him again) he actually questioned the official himself: ‘You want a fair referee, or a strong referee anyway… when I saw who the referee was I feared it. I feared the worst.’ But Fergie is by no means the only one. As stated earlier Wenger has been hyper-critical over the years, and in the short space of time Kenny Dalglish has been back in the Anfield dugout he has complained about the reds’ treatment, especially this season.
Continue Reading on Page 2 ...
WATCH LIVERPOOL V MAN UTD! 188BET are offering the opportunity of winning a 2 VIP Legend’s Lounge tickets for the match. Please click on the banner below to be in with a BIG chance of winning the massive prize!
–
–
–
[ad_pod id=”unruly-video” align=”center”]
I wish everyone would just get over it. Atkinson made a mistake but if you go sliding in you risk the ref getting it wrong. But and it is a big but Atkinson more than made up for it by not giving Hibbert and Fellani their marching orders both of whom are amongst the dirtiest players in the dirtiest team in the league and under their influence Rodwell should before long reach their high standard.
The reason is simple, referees are told to protect the games most talented players above others and I heard this straight from the horses mouth. Whilst watching the 2010 World Cup on Holiday in Egypt on Jazeeri Sport, I noticed during the build up to some of the games, one of the studio guests was Graham Poll. He made it clear that one of Fifa’s instructions to the referees before the World Cup was to make sure they protected the most gifted players. This is obviously an instruction that has been passed down to Uefa and therefore the Premier League too. At the time, I couldn’t actually believe what I was hearing as this is the most impartial and biased ruling i’ve ever heard in my life, and can hardly be looked upon as a democratic way of refereeing a football match. This will therefore explain why the top four or five clubs in this country are pampered so much by our referees and spoken to using their nick-names (something you’ll easily notice if you take the time to lip read the premier league referees during a game i.e Wassa instead of Wayne) whilst the rest of the league has to put up with being called by their first names or shirt numbers. This ruling will also explain why opposing players are booked every time they make a challenge (foul or not) whilst the the top teams have to commit 3 or 4 challenges to get their nick name taken.
It would be very interesting to hear what the managers of the other 15 Premier League teams have to say about this attempt by the powers that be to corrupt our once beautiful game.
So the answer to your question is, they are not making mistakes, just doing as they’re told
Bill, so what you are saying is that if you perform a perfectly good slide tackle, and the referee sends you off for it, then its your own fault because you went to ground?! On that basis then by walking onto the pitch, you risk the referee “getting it wrong” and sending you off.
when a ref takes a decision in just a few seconds, he makes use of what he sees not only in action but what he hears and feels.THIS no video in the world can replace. The sound and harshness of a tackle can be judge better on the pitch.
I completely agree and will further the point by adding no good could come from having the officials explain anything to the media. Could you imagine how quickly that situation would degenerate into a witch hunt or metaphorical lynching situation from some “reporter” trying to make a for themselves and the rag they represent.