LOAN signings have been the subject of quite a bit of controversy recently, especially when Manchester City’s players are involved. Let’s take Adebayor as an example, many turned their nose up at his loan signing for Spurs, seeing it as City doing their rivals a disservice as Adebayor could obviously play and score against them, but couldn’t play against his parent club, directly impacting on the race for the title. To some, loan deals are a way of ensuring you hoover up the best of the talent, to others it’s a great chance to send your kids away to get some valuable first team experience.
Whether this is the case or not, it’s not been too often we’ve been on the right end of a loan deal. We’ve loaned youngsters out with varying degrees of success ever since I can remember, we loaned Aquilani out to two different Italian clubs in an attempt to get his exorbitant wages off the bill and see if we couldn’t get him a move back to Italy, we sent Joe Cole out to Lille last season where he regained his form.
But rarely are we the ones doing the loaning in. We have been linked with two loan moves so far this window; we are rumoured to have approached Real Madrid for Nuri Sahin and Barcelona for their talented young forward Christian Tello.
I personally would like to see us pull more of these deals out of the fire rather than make catastrophic errors of judgement and sign players who do not fit or don’t settle. It’s not practical to get the best players on loan obviously.
Using Aquilani as an example, whilst he was, pound for pound arguably our worst ever signing, that wasn’t a deal we could have got done on loan. Roma simply would not have allowed it and rightly so.
But when you’re taking a gamble, why not look at the loan market? The last (first team) player we brought in on loan was one Javier Mascherano. When we signed him in the January on loan, The Chief was languishing in the West Ham reserves as Alan Pardew (who, let’s be honest, had probably never even heard of him when both he and Tevez appeared at Upton Park that crazy day) favoured Hayden Mullins. Fast forward five months and Mascherano is stood with his hands on his hips and his head down in the centre circle in Athens as we lost a European Cup final. He was one of the key components in that run to the final.
Obviously that deal was complicated because of the involvement of Kia Joor…. Kia Joorab…. That Iranian crook, and the Icelandic lunatics who were in charge of West Ham. But who is to say that similar value deals aren’t out there?
[ad_pod id=”unruly-video” align=”center”]
Let’s take Sahin and Tello as examples, and for what it’s worth I believe there is definite interest in Sahin, and Tello is being considered as a late window swoop. Do we need Sahin? Arguably not, but if the chance to sign a player that good comes along, you need to take it and consider how you need to manage your squad. We have a lot of central midfielders at the moment, but Sahin can play as an attacking player and is, I believe, equally comfortable playing deeper too. He didn’t play a lot for Madrid last season through injury. We present a good chance to get him back to full fitness and back in form for Real. Additionally, if they deem him surplus to requirements, we get the chance to sign him if he impresses. But by this point, we know exactly what sort of player we are signing because we’ve had him for a season already.
The same can be said about Tello. The young lad has all the pace and trickery but his finishing is, shall we say, erratic. But with Villa back for Barcelona, Tello might not play much if at all next season. We need another wide player in and we are looking to get one in if you believe the credible links to Theo Walcott and Adam Johnson. At such a young age Tello may or may not go on to be a superstar. But a year on loan abroad would do him no harm. It is mutually beneficial to Barcelona and us. They loan a bright young talent out, we benefit if he’s good, sign him if we like or send him back if he doesn’t cut it. Additionally if Barca like what they see they can get him back next summer that bit older, wiser and with more experience under his belt. That of course would potentially leave us jilted but that is the gamble you take.
There truly is no reason to not bring in a loan signing if the conditions are right. We sure as hell spend enough time loaning our players out, it’s about time we started to feel the benefits from the other side of the loan market.
[ad_pod id=’DFP-MPU’ align=’right’]
Live4Liverpool is recruiting columnists. For further info contact the site editor at live4liverpool@snack-media.com
Follow us on Twitter here: @live4Liverpool and ‘Like’ us on Facebook
loan players get in the way of our younger players development, we are already well off for midfielders and have players like Suso/Pacheco/Sterling waiting for their chance, i would only consider a loan deal in the event of an injury crisis
we should have got only sahin, allen was just not needed. Allen does not guarantee success, so he would be as much a gamble as sahin. but i’d put my money on an experienced player who has had more than one good season. Hardluck for him,he ended up at real,it’s not a place where you are given many chances to prove your worth, if you don’t make an immediate impact you off. robben,sneijder,VDV…ring a bell to y’all. Sahin is definitely world class and honestly i’ve seen enough of him to say he is heaps and bound better than Allen
definatly worth tryng a few loans, we’ve had clubs beefit from our players for the last few years, time to get some benefit ourselves. if we could get tello with an agreed fee on loan the thatd b great, if hes good we keep, if he sucks then we pull out like ac and juve did with aqua. cant see sahin being allowed on loan with an agreed fee though, he is class and im sure real will be wanting him back.
Reina
Johnson Skrtel Agger Enrique
Gerrard Lucas Allen
Ramirez Borini Suarez
Subs:Doni Kelly Carragher Coates Robinson Sahin Henderson Adam Tello Carroll Downing
YNWA
actually sell Adam and put Shelvey in his place
YNWA
You mean give Adam away, nobody in their right mind would pay for him.
They might if you throw a zimmer frame in too!
Pepe
Johnson skrtel agger Enrique
Sahin. Lucas. Allen
Gerrard. Suarez. Borini
Coates Kelly Henderson Carroll Tello Dempsey Butland
We USED to be a big club. It as we who loaned out players, now IT PROVES THAT WE ARE NOT BACKED BY OUR AMERCAN OWNERS. We continue to fall. So far this transfer window we have got rid of 7 players and brought 2 in – now we are looking for other clubs to lend us some players. Does that not not make you proud????
I’m sure any loan player will love it at Anfield with the great fans, and want to stay. Don’t forget our American owners saved us from Admin and possible relegation, an act that i for one will be eternally gratefull.
Your comments are way off base. They saved us from admin and spent a fortune on players. It will have cost a lot to ship Hodgson then Dalglish out along with their backroom staff too.
Two more in and two out, seems about right to me.
Give Adam & Cole away. Take Dempsey on a free in January. Sell Agger for £25m with Johnson to us on loan and invest the money made on a stiker who will scare the living daylights out of our opposition.
Adam, Cole and Spearing need to go, why not try to get Sahin and Tello on loan, saves the mistakes made from our last crop of buys, if they’re good make a offer, if not, were not stuck with them and their wages.YNWA.
That’s what they are trying to do.
Spearing and Adam are just not good enough, they should make way for Sahin, he is an absolute gem!